A very long time ago, a feature for providing arXiv trackbacks has been requested.

There is also a highly upvoted Meta StackExchange discussion, requesting the same functionality. Unfortunately, it seems like we are quite far from getting an official implementation of this highly impactful feature for a small subset of communities.

However, MathOverflow has their custom implementation and they are very willing to share! Thanks, ScottMorrison.

Now, I have the code for the script, and we have two options:

Option 1:

Run a slightly modified script on our server.

By our server, I mean not SE, but, say, a personal server of one of the highly-active members of the community. I have access to set up this script on one of the servers available to me.

  • We have the ability to control this script and, possibly, fix things independently from MathOverflow (still, I would probably go for some joint GitHub repository or so, provided the permission is granted).
  • We would have to arrange our own whitelisting with arXiv

Option 2:

Augment the provided script, and run it together with MathOverflow on their private server.

  • Less maintenance
  • I should be more careful modifying the script (as being "poked" by one community is a routine, while being "yelled" by two is certainly a party)

Soon, I am going to go over the code and see how much work should I do in development\testing\deployment. I welcome the opinions on this feature, implementation, scenarios, possible drawbacks, etc.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Excellent, thanks a lot for pursuing this! I believe option 2 would be preferable as far as possible; the main question is to identify if and what would be possible/desirable to change. I can't think of anything, except possibly the arXiv categories -- are these currently restricted? $\endgroup$ Jun 23, 2019 at 8:54
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ And the more code on github/gitlab/whatever, the better! $\endgroup$ Jun 23, 2019 at 8:54


You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .